WWE 2K23 {
} 7/10
I hadn't bought one of these games since the 2K16 version and a bit has changed over the years since then. I wish they'd just simplify the gameplay a little bit more.
I hate to compare this to the WWF games on N64, but I'm going to do just that. One of the reasons those games were so popular (and apparently still are, even though I feel they haven't aged too well) is because when a friend or relative would visit, they'd usually want to play even if they didn't give a crap about watching WWF on TV, the games were just that fun, and you could hand them a controller and explain everything they'd need to know to play within a minute. I don't think you'd be able to do that with this game. The matches are a lot more slow paced, just mashing buttons won't get you anywhere (so it's not noob-friendly). It's way more realistic than those N64 games which is both good and bad.
I feel like the Create-A-
Wrestler Superstar mode is a little too in-depth for its own good. In WWF No Mercy I could spend about 45-60 minutes creating my own custom wrestler, and that would include his entrance, moveset and alternate attires. Just on my one custom wrestler so far in this game I've spent almost 2 f'n hours creating him, with over 45 minutes of that being spent on his entrance alone (which I'm still not satisfied with due to glitches involving pyro), and spending a lot of time on his moveset but there's no way I'm sitting there to preview every available option. 20 years ago I would have, but not anymore.
Having not played one of these games since 2K16 version, I feel the graphics in 2K23 are a little bit of a letdown, or maybe I just expected a little more from the PS5 version. I felt the PS3 and Xbox 360 WWE games were held back a lot because they kept supporting the Wii and PS2 for longer than they should have instead of just taking full advantage of the next-gen hardware and I don't want a repeat of that with PS5 and XSX, so maybe just cut the PS4 and XB1 versions after this.
I had fun with the showcase mode, however it overall was not as good as I was hoping for. It focuses only on John Cena and he's one of those "love him or hate him" guys for most fans. I personally am somewhere in the middle. I realize there will always be a place for guys like him in the the industry (good physique, charismatic, but somewhat limited in-ring ability) so the women and children have someone to mark out for. It was fun to revisit some of his more famous matches, but I do have some complaints:
- They really botched some of the presentation in this mode. There is no commentary in any of the matches except for the last two, it's all just generic rock music in the rest of the matches.
- At a few points some of the FMV clips are pixelated and gross, almost as if they ripped the clips off of old YouTube videos instead of getting them from WWE directly.
- During the matches some parts turn into a cutscene (a mixture of the in-game character models and FMV clips) to segue you into the next point of the match, but some of the cutscenes felt too long.
- They had to censor way too much stuff in the FMV cutscenes. Referee faces (wtf?), commentary team's faces, faces of the ringside photographers, and also the logos on John Cena's sneakers and wristbands. It looks terrible when you see all of those things on-screen at the same and having to be blurred out.
After that I tried out the MyRise mode which you use a created character to play through an original storyline. It offers two storylines and I've only played through one so far, but I liked it and it offers a few kinda inside references to the "smart" fans. They encourage you to play through it twice to see the different available paths you take depending on choices you've made but I don't know if I'll be doing that.
My original intention was to play through the Showcase mode and then toss this up on Craigslist by WrestleMania weekend to get some of my money back. I eventually decided I'm not doing that. After exploring more of the game's features and what it offers, I'm okay with keeping this in my collection for good. I doubt I'll go back to where I buy these games yearly, but I was pleased with this one after being away from the series for so long.