Forum Search

Scott wrote:

i dont know why, but i was kind of underwhelmed by mario wonder. I don't know why because it really did have its claws in me. I felt the drive to keep playing every chance I got. BUt something felt off for me.

It's been a really slow year for me, but I managed to beat another game, Super Mario Wonder. My son and I played through it co-op. I also have another save file going where I'm playing through it solo.

NES -
SNES -
N64 -
GC -
Wii -
Wii U - Yoshi's Woolly World
Switch - Pokemon Scarlet, Super Mario Wonder
GB -
GBC -
GBA -
DS -
3DS -
360 -
XB1 -
PS1 -
PS2 -
PS4 -
PSP -
GEN -

2/19 - Unique systems

3 - Total games

The Legend of Zelda has blown the whistle and ridden a whirlwind to parts unknown. Here's a look at everyone who saved Hyrule this month:

BleedingViolet image image Renaissance2K image

Many thanks to everyone that dipped their toes into this classic Nintendo title this month. If you started your journey but didn't manage to finish before the end of November, feel free to let me know when the credits roll so you can receive your badge.

It was a quiet month, but here's the final tally for December's Game of the Month:

1. Zelda II: The Adventure of Link - 14 points
2. Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars - 13 points
3. Kirby 64: The Crystal Shards - 10 points
4. Blaster Master: Enemy Below - 9 points
5. Pikmin 2 - 7 points
6. Duke Nukem 3D - 4 points
7. Shadow Hearts - 2 points
7. Cold Fear - 2 points

Remembered often as the "black sheep" of the Zelda franchise, Zelda II: The Adventure of Link continues the story of Link's first NES adventure and frames it with more RPG-leaning features. Link traverses Hyrule via a sparse overworld map, visits towns to speak to Hylian townsfolk and gather resources, and explores wilderness and temples via new side-scrolling action segments. Like its predecessor, Zelda II has been ported to nearly every iteration of Nintendo's classic games library, got its own cartridge re-release for the Game Boy Advance, and even its own Game & Watch-styled modern handheld.

Play Zelda II: The Adventure of Link on
Nintendo NES
Game Boy Advance (Classic NES Series)
GameCube (via The Legend of Zelda: Collector's Edition)
Wii (Virtual Console)
Wii U (Virtual Console)
3DS (Virtual Console)
Switch (Nintendo Switch Online)
NES Classic Edition
The Legend of Zelda Game & Watch

Finish any version or port of Zelda II: The Adventure of Link to earn the Zelda II Link badge: Badge coming soon...

Don't be Error. Share a #BeatIt screenshot.

December is also the last month to complete the Annual Franchise Challenge and complete a game in the Shining franchise to get an icon next to your name. Between bursts of holiday shopping, there's a lot of gaming to do. Have fun!

https://www.amazon.com/gp/redirect.html?ie=UTF8&lo...
Offer Ends on the 28th
PS5 Final Fantasy 16 Bundle $300-400 https://www.amazon.com/gp/redirect.html?ie=UTF8&lo...
Super Mario Wonder $10-45 https://www.amazon.com/gp/redirect.html?ie=UTF8&lo...-Mario-Bros-TM-Wonder-Nintendo-Version/dp/B0C8VHZR14/ref=sr_1_5?m=A2L77EE7U53NWQ&qid=1700764876&s=warehouse-deals&sr=1-5
Xbox Series X $400 Diablo 4 Bundle and Non Bundle $250 https://www.amazon.com/gp/redirect.html?ie=UTF8&lo...64704&rd=1&s=warehouse-deals&sr=8-46
Company of Heroes 3 Premium Edition $30 https://www.amazon.com/gp/redirect.html?ie=UTF8&lo...64770&rd=1&s=warehouse-deals&sr=8-134
Dualsense Various Colors $10-40 https://www.amazon.com/gp/redirect.html?ie=UTF8&lo...64844&rd=1&s=warehouse-deals&sr=8-8&th=1
Nintendo Switch V1 $160-220 https://www.amazon.com/gp/redirect.html?ie=UTF8&lo...64728&rd=1&s=warehouse-deals&sr=8-52
Bayonetta 3 $40-50 https://www.amazon.com/gp/redirect.html?ie=UTF8&lo...64803&rd=1&s=warehouse-deals&sr=8-173

Well Amazon won this Black Friday for me, Passed on Bayonetta 3 CE for $40 and the switch didn't seem worth it even at $160. Probably one of the better 20% off AWD Days. $420 for a PS5, Final Fantasy 16, PSN for Alan Wake 2, 3 Copies of Super Mario Wonder and a Dualsense hoping for more drops.

Super Mario RPG: 5
Kirby 64: 5
Zelda II: 4

It's been pretty quiet here, but hope everybody's got a good game or two to keep them warm as the weather starts to cool off. Who else is still working their way through The Legend of Zelda?

I'm about to start travelling for Thanksgiving, so I wanted to kick off our plans for next month a little early. As we talked about before, in the spirit of holiday redemption, end of the year crunches, and other time-honored traditions, December will be a redemption month where we give games that finished in second place throughout the year another chance to be in the spotlight. That list is below.

Nominees
Duke Nukem 3D *n64*
Pikmin 2
Shadow Hearts
Zelda II: The Adventure of Link
Kirby 64: The Crystal Shards *n64*
Blaster Master: Enemy Below
Cold Fear
Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars

Either publicly in this thread or privately in a PM to me, give each nominee 0-5 points. Omitting a nominee is equivalent to giving it a vote of 0. The game with the highest score by the end of the month will be the December 2023 GOTM.

Here are my votes:

Duke Nukem 3D - 4 Pikmin 2 - 3 Shadow Hearts - 2 Zelda II: The Adventure of Link - 5 Kirby 64: The Crystal Shards - 5 Blaster Master: Enemy Below - 4 Cold Fear - 2 Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars - 3

Submit your votes, and let's see who gets a second (or third) chance.

Just trying to get rid of some stuff I really don't need or play. I will only be accepting PayPal F&F and I only ship within the USA. I require insurance for any purchase over $100 and my local Post Office almost never lets me ship stuff via Media Mail. I can send pictures for any games you are interested in and my page will break down the actual condition. Just send me a PM and your email address and I will send you the pics of the games Please note the last time I checked these games the saves still worked but these games are much as 30 years old and batteries will need to be replaced at some point. Please check my list as I have many more games on there. Must be of a purchase of at least $20. Thanks for reading.


NES

Advanced Dungeon and Dragons: HillsFar (cart only with some minor label damage) $135 shipped with insurance included. Pending out

Battletoads (cart only) the very top of the label is peeling.
MetalMech (cart only) has a few stickers on it as it must have been a rental.
Arkanoid (cart only) a little damage to the front label


Sega Saturn

Magic Knight Rayearth (complete in good shape IMPORT)
make sure your game system can play imports



PlayStation (PSX)

Legacy of Kain Soul Reader (complete) but was part of the collectors set
Martian Gothic (complete)
Jumping Flash (disc only) in fair shape



PS2


The Simpson's Game (disc only)
R type Final. (complete) disc in fair shape and instructions must have been wet




PS3

Monopoly Streets (complete)
Call of Duty Blacks combo pack (complete)



Nintendo DS

Personal Trainer Math (cart only) game is a little fidgety but works not sure if its my DS or the cart you may have to try it a couple times
Nintendogs (cart only) game is a little fidgety but works might have to put in and out a couple times
Puss in Boots (cart only)
Harry Potter & the Half Blood Prince (cart only)
Chronicles of Narnia (cart only)
Alice in Wonderland (cart only)
all 6 of these DS games here for $23 shipped. Or for $3 more on this deal I will add a 3DS carry case that holds 8 carts and the system but I only ship this in a mailer.





3DS

Pokemon Alpha Sapphire (complete but it came with a digital manual)
Garfield Kart (unopened).
Pokemon Sun (cart only).


GBA, Gameboy, and Game boy Color

Tailspin (cart only) for Gameboy
Solar Striker (cart only) for Gameboy
Duck tales 2 (cart Gly) for Gameboy
TMNT Fall of the Foot clan (cart only) for Gameboy
Pokemon Pinball (cart only) and some label damage for GBC
Donkey Kong Country (cart only) for GBC
Legend of Zelda Links Awakening (cart only) Gameboy
Final Fantasy Legend (cart only) with a little label damage GB



Sega Genesis

Afterburner II (complete)
Bimini Run (cart and case only)
Rocket Knight Adventures (cart only with a little label damage)
Battletoads (cart only with a good amount of label damage)
Jurassic Park Rampage Edition (cart only)
ToeJam and Earl. (cart only)
Road Rash 3 (complete) read my listing for condition
Valis (cart only)
Game Genie (cart only)

World of Illusion (cart only) label in rough shape
Lethal Enforcers (cart only) label in fair shape but must have had a rental stickers torn off
Lethal Enforcers 2 (cart only) label in fair shape but shows a lot of wear
Hook (cart only) label in fair shape and some of the label torn at the top
Mickey Mania (cart only) label in fair shape with a tear near the top
Pink Goes to Hollywood (cart only) in fair shape
The Tick (cart only) in fair shape
Sonic 3 (cart only) label in really rough shape also something loose inside it
Tiny Toon Adv. Hidden Treasure (cart only) label in rough shape with some of sticker torn
Desert Demolition (cart only) label tear in rough shape something rattling around inside
Tom & Jerry Frantic Antics (cart only) in rough shape
Scooby Too Mystery (cart only) again in really poor shape on label
Bubsy II (cart only) label in fair shape




Nintendo 64

Mario Party (cart only but was a previous rental and has a couple stickers)
Batman Beyond (cart only)
Resident Evil 2 (cart only)



Nintendo Wii & Wii U

Mario Party 8 (complete disc in fair shape)

Just Dance (disc and case only) for Wii U
The Lego Movie Video Game (complete) for Wii U
Resident Evil 4 (sealed) for Wii
The Black Eyed Peas Experience (sealed but the disc is loose in the case) for Wii



Sega Game Gear


Primal Rage (cart only)
Shaq Fu (cart only)
Mortal Kombat 2 (cart only)
Sonic Chaos (cart only)

Add me to the pile of people that jumped on Mario's newest platformer this month.

Number: 77
Full Title: 64842684" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" title="twitter.com/Renaissance2K/status/1723972923864842684 (secure)">Super Mario Bros. Wonder
Platform Played: Switch
Collection: N/A
Native Platform: Switch
Original Platforms: Switch
Applicable Badge: Hop 'n' Bop (already earned)

My little sister, who was visiting for my birthday, joined me in-game when I booted up Wonder for the first time. I don't think I've had so much fun playing couch co-op in years. The simplified multiplayer physics (we're no longer bouncing off each other and throwing our friends into cliffs) coupled with the "What are the Wonder drugs going to do to Mario this time?" effect turned the game into a fast-paced, giggly, colorful adventure. Even the ambient online mode, where random online ghosts play through the same levels concurrently - dropping hints and "help me" emojis as they go - adds so much personality to the game that's conspicuously missing if I'm playing the game on the go without an Internet connection.

I did not buy into any of the gimmicks when the game first launched. The new art style seemed unnecessary. The Flower Kingdom means nothing to me. The Wonder Flower mechanics seemed like out of character no-ops that change the gameplay without adding to it. "Just give me more New Super Mario with some new levels, bosses, power-ups, and let's call it a day," I thought. Man, was I wrong. Having played through the game now, though, I don't know how I could have been happy with anything less than what we got. Every level managed to feel like a completely new, standalone Mario experience that still managed to hang onto the little red plumber's core DNA. Amazing stuff.

I'm continuing to work through Final Fantasy XVI slowly, and I've picked back up Tears of the Kingdom, which has been pushed aside by a number of meaty portable titles.

Looking to sell a tested and working black Nintendo 64 system. Comes with seven games two controllers the hookups and expansion pack . The games include Mario kart 64 perfect dark Star Wars shawdow of the empire rogue squadron goldeneye wrestlemania 2000. Looking to get 175 FnF but I’m also open to offers . Just trying to get cash for Xmas

With my birthday month over, it's back to business as usual, playing through two games to satisfy objectives in the Retro Talkshop Thread.

Number: 75
Full Title: The Legend of Zelda
Platform Played: Super Nintendo
Collection: N/A
Native Platform: Nintendo NES
Original Platforms: Nintendo NES
Applicable Badge: Hyrulian Hero (1/2)

This is another fan port of a NES classic to the SNES by Infidelty, in the same vein as Mega Man 2 from last month. Despite being the very first NES game I ever witnessed, back in 1987, I didn't complete it until a few years ago on the NES Mini. The SNES version is a subtle-yet-remarkable improvement. Aside from a few bugs that are just as funny as they are unfortunate, the improved performance adds a lot of snap to the gameplay, and the ability to rotate through items without entering the menu is a QOL improvement whose benefits cannot be understated. I had a real blast with this one.

Number: 76
Full Title: Shining in the Darkness
Platform Played: Genesis
Collection: N/A
Native Platform: Genesis
Original Platforms: Genesis
Applicable Badge: Level Up! (already earned)

To complete the Retro Talkshop Thread's Annual Franchise Challenge, I feel like I've been playing through this old school JRPG dungeon crawler for ages, but Backloggery is telling me that I started this in August, less than three months ago. The artwork, battle system, and sense of humor made this game a whole lot more enjoyable, but I'm not sure how era-accurate me would have stood up to the task without save states and maps. The required backtracking, single save point, and unexpected traps made dungeon traversal a whole lot more frustrating than I would have liked. That said, when the game isn't trying to stab you in the back, it's a fun game that I don't see myself replaying in the future without some quality of life updates.

I've picked Final Fantasy XVI back up in earnest, though I'm growing increasingly skeptical of my ability to finish the game before the end of 2023. On the portable front, I'm enthralled by Super Mario Bros. Wonder. Playing solo is nowhere near the giddy experience I had playing side-by-side with my little sister just after launch, but it's still a refreshing take on an ancient formula.

BloodPuppetX wrote:

Nintendo is just so lazy with their special editions. If they just went back to the N64 translucent days, they'd move so many consoles.

Alright in need of some funds so will parting with some items from collection . Feel free to shoot me offers if you would like worse i can say is no.

Nintendo systems
Top Loader with Dogbone Controller $125


Senran kagura deep crimson Double D Edtion (complete) $40
Etrian Mystery Dungeon (Sealed) $100
Yokai Watch Blasters Dog Squad (complete) $190
Kid Icarus Uprising (big box complete with Sealed AR cards, missing stand) $50

gb*
Gargoyles Quest (cart only) $30

*n64*
Mickey Magical Tetris (complete) $50


Beach Spikers (complete) $15
True Crime New York City (complete) $20


Muramasa Demon Blade (complete) $30
Fishing Resort (with Case) $40
Juon The Grudge (complete) $70
Trauma Team (complete) $40


Sands of Destruction (cart only) $40


Devils Third (Sealed) $260


Super Mario RPG (Sealed) $40
Mario Bros Wonder (complete) $40
Legend of Heroes Trails to Azure deluxe edition (complete) $70
Shantae Pirates Curse (Sealed) $290
The Messenger (Sealed) $200
Samurai Showdown (with Case) $100
Blasphemous (Sealed) $70
Hyper Parasite (Sealed) $30
rune factory 5 earthmate edition (complete) $30
Monkey Barrels (Sealed) $20
Touken Ranbu Warriors (complete) $30
Creature in the Well (Sealed) $25
Salt & Sanctuary (complete) $60
Guns of Mercy (sealed) $25


Zombies Ate My Neighbors (complete) $80
Breath of Fire 1 $120
Breath of Fire 2 (with box and manual) $190
Raiden Trad (with box) $45
https://imgur.com/gallery/U94g5V5
https://imgur.com/gallery/tzF0Mk3




Skies of Arcadia (complete) $100
Sonic Shuffle (complete) $40
Sonic Adventure (complete) $45
Mark of the Wolves (complete) $70


TMNT Hypersone Heist (complete) $100

Sony Systems



Lifeline (complete) $40
Red Star (complete) $40


Legend of heroes Trails to Azure deluxe edition (Sealed) $70
Y’s IX pact edition (complete) $25
Cold Steel 3 Early Enrollment Edition (sealed) $30
Rock Band 4 (with case) $35


Metal Gear Acid 2 (complete)$45
Metal Gear Acid 1 (complete) $25 or both for $60

Microsoft



Mushihimesama Futari Ver 1.5 (Import region free complete) $35
Lego Lord of the Rings (complete) $15
Agarest War Zero Limited Edition (Sealed) $30

Alright in need of some funds so will parting with some items from collection . Feel free to shoot me offers if you would like worse i can say is no.

Nintendo systems
Top Loader with Dogbone Controller $125


Senran kagura deep crimson Double D Edtion (complete) $40
Etrian Mystery Dungeon (Sealed) $100
Yokai Watch Blasters Dog Squad (complete) $180
Kid Icarus Uprisng ( big box complete AR cards sealed missing stand ) $50

gb*
Gargoyles Quest (cart only) $30

*n64*
Mickey Magical Tetris (complete) $50


Beach Spikers (complete) $15
True Crime New York City (complete) $20


Muramasa Demon Blade (complete) $30
Fishing Resort (with Case) $40
Juon The Grudge (complete) $70
Trauma Team (complete) $40


Sands of Destruction (cart only) $40


Devils Third (Sealed) $260


Super Mario RPG (Sealed) $40
Mario Bros Wonder (complete) $40
Legend of Heroes Trails to Azure deluxe edition (complete) $70
Shantae Pirates Curse (Sealed) $290
The Messenger (Sealed) $200
Samurai Showdown (with Case) $100
Blasphemous (Sealed) $70
Hyper Parasite (Sealed) $30
rune factory 5 earthmate edition (complete) $30
Monkey Barrels (Sealed) $20
Touken Ranbu Warriors (complete) $30
Creature in the Well (Sealed) $25
Salt & Sanctuary (complete) $60
Guns of Mercy (sealed) $25


Zombies Ate My Neighbors (complete) $80
Breath of Fire 1 $120
Breath of Fire 2 (with box and manual) $190
Raiden Trad (with box) $45
https://imgur.com/gallery/U94g5V5
https://imgur.com/gallery/tzF0Mk3




Skies of Arcadia (complete) $100
Sonic Shuffle (complete) $40
Sonic Adventure (complete) $45
Mark of the Wolves (complete) $70


TMNT Hypersone Heist (complete) $100

Sony Systems



Lifeline (complete) $40
Red Star (complete) $40


Legend of heroes Trails to Azure deluxe edition (Sealed) $70
Y’s IX pact edition (complete) $25
Cold Steel 3 Early Enrollment Edition (sealed) $30
Rock Band 4 (with case) $35


Metal Gear Acid 2 (complete)$45
Metal Gear Acid 1 (complete) $25 or both for $60

Microsoft



Mushihimesama Futari Ver 1.5 (Import region free complete) $35
Lego Lord of the Rings (complete) $15
Agarest War Zero Limited Edition (Sealed) $30

Number: 26
Full Title: Super Mario Wonder
Platform Played:
Collection: N/A
Native Platform:
Original Platform:
Applicable Badge: Hop 'n' Bop (1/2)

image

I've gotten 100% on the six main worlds and the hub world but haven't finished all of the Special World yet. I think I am missing ~15 standees as well and haven't gotten any of the badges unlocked after beating the game. The Switch says I'm over 15 hours. I wish it were more precise, but there is a lot of meat here. I am definitely in the camp that says this game annihilates the series. I also feel it is much stronger than its Switch contemporary, Odyssey.

Scott wrote:


Available 11/9

Excited for the tracks in bold.

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Booster Course Pass Wave 6 trailer:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0-kASUEEXn8

Looks pretty solid. I'm super bummed that after 6 waves, they still haven't added N64 Wario Stadium. It's the only MK64 track that hasn't been remade in a newer MK game.

I'm beat with what will probably be a post-Halloween hangover, so I'm going to spare my usual summaries for this final birthday extravaganza update and get it in before midnight so as not to disrupt the monthly tallies.

Number: 72
Full Title: Twisted Metal: Head-On
Platform Played: PSP
Collection: N/A
Native Platform: PSP
Original Platforms: PSP
Applicable Badge: Mass Destruction (already earned)

Number: 73
Full Title: 6482867 (secure)" href="https://twitter.com/Renaissance2K/status/1719371156296482867" target="_blank">MDK
Platform Played: PC (Windows)
Collection: N/A
Native Platform: PC (Windows)
Original Platforms: PC, PlayStation
Applicable Badge: N/A

Number: 74
Full Title: Mega Man Powered Up
Platform Played: PSP
Collection: N/A
Native Platform: PSP
Original Platforms: PSP
Applicable Badge: Heavy Machine Gun (already earned)

I need to stay caught up with bills as I apply for work. Payment by PayPal Friends & Family, Cash App, or Zelle. Buy 3 or more items and get 10% off. Prices include shipping. No layaway or setting aside. If you find a better legitimate deal, I’ll match it or do a better price.

Please send offers or Private Messages if interested.

Prices are as listed or best offer.
*Additional items added sporadically



Miscellaneous (Misc.) [ mis-uh-ley-nee-us] adjective;

Arris Surfboard (SB8200) 3.1 Cable Modem (Used, no box unless it’s found) - $44.

Flip-A-Zoo Lion/Monkey plush on a keychain (New) - $11

New Gardner Bender Digital Multimeter (New in package) - $18

Honeywell Home Wi-Fi Thermostat RTH6500WF (Open Box never installed) - $22.

Honeywell Home THP9045A C-Wire Adapter Wi-Fi Thermostat Accessory (Gently used – didn’t work for my furnace) - $12.

Ice Cube Making Bottle (Ice Ball Mold) (Like new) - $12.

jellyfish light up the tank. (New in box) - $15

Peloton glass water bottle (New in box) - $10

Peloton x Urbanears Sumpan Earbuds (New) - $12

SodaStream: 2x Bubly bounce drops: Citrus Berry - $10

Soulfina Graffiti Crossbody Sling Backpack Daypack Travel Chest Bag (PETA – Approved VEGAN) (Unused) - $44

T-Mobile Tuesdays Pride socks Medium/Large (Unopened) - $8

Music:

Harry Styles: Fine Line on Vinyl (Gently used) - $27

Movies:

Walt Disney Pictures: Bolt (Disc Only) - $3

Bruce Lee Ultimate Collection - $16

Games:

Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) October 18, 1985

N/A

Game Boy (GB) April 21, 1989

N/A

Super Nintendo (SNES) November 21, 1990

N/A

Nintendo 64 (N64) September 26, 1996

N/A

Game Boy Color (GBC) October 21, 1998

N/A

Game Boy Advance (GBA) June 11, 2001

N/A

Nintendo GameCube (GC) September 14, 2001

Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door (Box ❌ and/or Manual ❌) $68

Nintendo DS (NDS) November 21, 2004

N/A

Nintendo Wii (Wii) November 19, 2006

N/A

Nintendo Wii U (U) November 18, 2012

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (Box ✅ and/or Manual ❌) - $20

Nintendo Switch (NSW) Current Gen? March 3, 2017

N/A

Sega Genesis (Gen) August 14, 1989

N/A

Sega Saturn (SS) May 11, 1995

N/A

Sega Dreamcast (DC) September 9, 1999

N/A

Microsoft Xbox (OG Xbox) November 15, 2001

N/A

PlayStation 1 (PS) “The following games have ALL been painstakingly tested. Titles that didn’t function as expected have already been removed. Pictures of games working are available upon request”.

Final Fantasy VII [Greatest Hits] (Box ❌ and/or Manual ❌) - $17

The Legend of Dragoon (Box ❌ and/or Manual ❌) - $26

PlayStation 2 (PS2) March 4, 2000

N/A

PlayStation 3 (PS3) November 17, 2006

N/A

PlayStation Portable (PSP) March 24, 2005

N/A

PlayStation 4 (PS4) November 15, 2013

N/A

PlayStation 5 (PS5) Current Generation November 12, 2020

N/A

Xbox 360 (360) November 22, 2005

N/A

Xbox One (XBONE) November 22, 2013

N/A

Xbox Series X (XSX) Current Generation November 10, 2020

N/A

“Please take care of me, I’ll take care of you too.”

Think this is mine. It could all change except for my #1.

Super Mario World (1990, 1991)
Super Mario Bros. 3 (1988, 1990)
Super Mario Sunshine (2002)
Super Mario Galaxy (2007)
Super Mario Bros. Wonder (2023)
Super Mario 64 (1996)
Super Mario Galaxy 2 (2010)
Super Mario Bros. (1985)
Super Mario Bros. 2 (USA, 1988)
Super Mario Odyssey (2017)
Super Mario 3D World (2013)
Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins (1992)
Bowser's Fury (2021)
Super Mario 3D Land (2011)
New Super Mario Bros. U (2012)
Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels (1986)
Super Mario Land (1989)
New Super Mario Bros. (2006)
New Super Mario Bros. Wii (2009)
New Super Mario Bros. 2 (2012)

I like this. My list is very similar to KCPenguins' list.

Cape Tier
SMB 1
SMB 3
Super Mario World
Super Mario Galaxy
Super Mario Galaxy 2
Super Mario 3D World
New Super Mario Bros U & Luigi U
Super Mario Odyssey

Tanooki Tier
Bowser's Fury
Super Mario Sunshine
NSMB Wii
Super Mario 3D Land

Helicopter Hat Tier
SMB2
Mario 64
NSMB
Super Mario Wonder (maybe this moves up by the time I'm done, but I'm very unimpressed as of now)
Super Mario Land 2

Frog Suit on a Non-Water Level Tier
NSMB2
Super Mario Land
SMB The Lost Levels

Mario Tier
SMB 3
SMB 1
Super Mario World
Super Mario Wonder
Super Mario 3D World & Land
Odyssey

Luigi Tier
SMB 2
Galaxy
NSMB 1 & Wii
Mario Land 2

Peach Tier
SM64
Sunshine
NSMB2
Lost Levels

Waluigi Tier
Mario Land 1 (It's ok but very short)

I haven't played NSMB U (or Luigi U) enough to rate it. Still haven't played Galaxy 2 at all.

I prefer to split mine up between 2D and 3D.

Edit: This is mostly based on how much I enjoy them today, not how good they were for their time. Nostalgia definitely factors in though.

2D
Super Mario Bros. 3 (1988, 1990)
Super Mario World (1990, 1991)
Super Mario Bros. Wonder (2023)
New Super Mario Bros. U (2012)
---
New Super Mario Bros. Wii (2009)
New Super Mario Bros. 2 (2012)
New Super Mario Bros. (2006)
---
Super Mario Bros. (1985)
Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels (1986)
Super Mario Bros. 2 (USA, 1988)
Super Mario Land (1989)
---
Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins (1992)

I'm very tempted to put Wonder first. But, I don't think that would be fair, since I haven't even completed the game yet. All 4 games in the top tier are very close, as are the 3 in the middle tier. I enjoy all of the games in the 3rd tier, but each has a major shortcoming that holds it back (SMB1 and SMB:LL have awful controls, SML is too short, and SMB2 just has an oddness to it that I don't quite like). I'm not much of a fan of 6 Golden Coins at all. I know people will hate me for that, but I just don't like the style of that game.

3D
Super Mario 3D World (2013)
Super Mario Odyssey (2017)
Super Mario Galaxy (2007)
Super Mario Galaxy 2 (2010)
---
Super Mario 64 (1996)
Super Mario 3D Land (2011)
Bowser's Fury (2021)
---
Super Mario Sunshine (2002)

All 4 games in my top tier are EXTREMELY close. I could honestly see ranking any one of them as my #1. I tend to put 3D World and Odyssey at the top, and a lot of that is due to the huge amount of nostalgia I have from playing them with my kids when they were little. Bowser's Fury could be higher, but it's too short. I've tried Sunshine two different times in my life and have not been able to get into it. I plan to give it one more chance, on the Switch. I hope to at least be able to finish it this time, but I doubt it's going to improve enough that I rank it higher than any of the other 3D games.

Super Mario 3D Land was so good. I didn't like Super Mario 3D World as much. I still enjoyed it and I'm not saying it was a bad game at all, but for a while it was my least favorite 3D Mario (that is until they released Super Mario 3D All-stars and I revisited SM64 and Sunshine and saw how poorly they aged).

I think what disappointed me was the emphasis on co-op and in 2013 they still didn't think there should have been an option for it to be online. I'm a huge fan of co-op games, but the people I enjoy playing them with the most are all over the world, making local co-op play impossible.
In addition to that, nothing really felt like the game was designed for co-op, and by that I mean every collectible could be reached in single player, you never needed anyone else's help to get them, nor were there any secret levels that could only be accessed in co-op. Like the NSMB games it was built first as a standard single player Mario title, co-op was just an option to make things more hectic. I'm fine with that, but I feel Sackboy did co-op better.

I still have not completed Champions Road and I need to do that one of these days. Maybe I'll make that one of my gaming goals of 2024. I've spent many hours on difficult levels in Super Mario Maker, sometimes over an hour on each level failing and failing and failing some more, because I was determined not to give up until I complete them, I don't know why I never felt the same desire to complete this one level, but I need to finally do it.

My Tiers: