justin_credible wrote:> Isn't Baldur's Gate going to win GOTY or is a nominee. It's a turn based game that
> isn't catering to COD fans or any other type of fans and selling really well. I don't
> buy that making Final Fantasy an action game means more sales anyway. It may not
> have happened yet but sooner or later classic rpg lovers will protest with their
> wallet and I don't see anyone going "I hate rpgs but I'm going to buy Final Fantasy
> because it's more action oriented now". To me it's an exercise in stupidity. And
> I mean no disrespect to people that enjoy 15 and/or 16 for example if you enjoyed
> it great I just don't think you bought it in hopes of a pure action game but maybe
> I'm wrong.
>
> It's like Resident Evil 5 came out and there was a big discussion about it being
> more like a third person COD shooter than a horror game especially when you played
> as Chris. The game sold well but I doubt it was because people that previously had
> no interest in the series went "Resident Evil is not scary anymore and I can go pew
> pew so I'll buy it" it was more like because it was the first HD Resident Evil and
> it had co-op.
Baldur's Gate III is the sequel to one of the most celebrated hardcore PC games of all time, which was released a whopping 23 years ago. Pent-up demand + great word of mouth - two decades of watering down the franchise with more lukewarm spin-offs than The Walking Dead on AMC = you win 2023.
And yeah, I totally agree the "change everything, win friends" approach is at best inefficient, at least ineffective, and at worst destructive. But the people who know that in the gaming industry - Hell, in most digital industries - are the ones taking orders from higher-ups or buying the end product, not the ones making decisions.